You cannot continue to play PS Plus Extra and Premium titles that have been removed from the service

Sony Interactive Entertainment has introduced the new PlayStation Plus version, which includes Basic, Extra and Premium levels, two new levels that feature access to more than 400 PS5 and PS4 games.

Although Sony announced in May that you can play games while they’re available on the service, the service’s arrival was accompanied by information that games like NBA 2K22 and Red Dead Redemption 2 (among others) already had a date to leave PS Plus Extra, Which is causing some confusion.

PS Plus Extra and Premium, like Microsoft’s Game Pass, allow access to hundreds of games with a subscription and you can play them while they’re on the list of titles available to you with that subscription.

This is what Sony wrote in May:

Similar to PlayStation Now, if content is no longer available on PlayStation Plus, you won’t be able to access games when they leave the service. If the title is available in the PlayStation Store and you decide you want to buy it, I’ll be able to use your save again, just make sure you don’t delete What is saved.”

The PS Plus Extra and Premium catalog does not work like the monthly offers in Essential, which are available to you once you add them to the library with an active subscription.